Legacy Leases under the New Lease Accounting Standard

By Calvin Rowland, HoganTaylor Assurance Partner

For many of you involved in preparation of financial statements ASU 2016-2, Leases, is in the back of your mind.  But with another 3 or 4 years before it’s an issue, you most likely don’t plan on addressing implementation anytime soon.   I am not going to raise the red flag yet but I will say that the new lease standard is big and it changes a lot of accounting that has been around for a long time. It’s not something you want to learn everything about overnight.  With that in mind, let’s give your future self a little break and breakdown one of the first things future you will need to know: What happens with the leases already in place when the new standard is adopted?

Lessee Accounting Summary

Before we discuss lessee implementation requirements on legacy leases, let’s briefly summarize accounting under the new standard.

Leases of property, plant or equipment will be capitalized.  There will be a right-of-use asset and lease liability on the balance sheet. You may elect an accounting policy not to capitalize leases with terms 12 months or less.

You initially measure the liability at the present value of the unpaid lease payments.  The initial right-of-use asset equals the amount of the lease liability plus various adjustments such as initial direct lease costs.

There will be two categories of leases: financing and operating.   For financing leases, you amortize the right-of-use asset over the shorter of the lease term or the right-of-use asset’s useful life, recognize interest expense on the liability and reduce the liability as you make lease payments.  For operating leases, you reduce the asset over the lease term and reduce the liability as you make lease payments. However, you will recognize a single lease expense, usually on a straight-line basis over the lease term.

Adoption Date

For private companies, the lease standard is effective years beginning after December 15, 2019, and must be applied retroactively by adjusting beginning equity at the earliest comparative financial statement period presented.  So if you are a calendar year private company that presents two year comparative financial statements that means it will be effective for the year ending December 31, 2020, and beginning equity will be adjusted as of January 1, 2019.  Let’s assume this is your scenario for the remainder of the article.

Practical Expedients

Your first step is determining whether or not to elect certain practical expedients.  You can’t pick and choose to apply the practical expedients to some leases and not others; your choices are policy elections that apply to all of your legacy leases.  Furthermore you must elect all or none of the following practical expedients:

  1. No reassessment of whether any expired or existing contracts contain leases under the new standard.
  2. Assume that capital leases under the old standard are financing leases under the new standard and operating leases under the old standard are operating leases under the new standard.
  3. No redetermination of initial direct costs for existing leases.

Expedient number (2.) probably stands out as the big time saver but number (1.) could be more significant if you have entered into a large number of service contracts that potentially could include embedded leases under the new standard.

Should you adopt the practical expedients?  For most of us, the answer is likely yes based on the effort it would save as well as the reduced risk of a misstatement.  I suppose if your existing leases are highly significant to your financial statements and the determinations could result in critical differences to financial statement outcomes, you may decide to invest the additional time to perform the detailed analysis on your existing leases and contracts.  For example, if you have significant operating leases that were close to meeting the criteria of capital leases under the old standards and you believed that going forward the expense associated with the leases should not be included in EBITDA, you might decide its worthwhile to see if the leases would be classified as financing under the new standard.

There is another practical expedient that you can choose to elect independently of your decision on the previous practical expedients.  It allows you to use hindsight in determining lease terms and in assessing impairments on right-of-use assets when implementing the standard.

For the remainder of the article, let’s assume that you decide to elect all the practical expedients.

Existing Lease Measurement

The next step is measuring the asset and liability of existing leases at adoption.  A full retrospective adoption approach is prohibited.  Instead you must use a modified retrospective approach.  This is significant because it means when you prepare your 2020 financial statements, you don’t have to go back to day one for every existing lease and apply the new lease standard as if it had been in place from the beginning of each lease.

Operating leases

For existing operating leases, the modified retrospective approach measures the asset and liability for existing leases as of the beginning of the earliest comparative financial statement period unless the lease commencement date is later.  So, if the lease began before January 1, 2019, you would measure the asset and liability based on the remaining payments and terms as of January 1, 2019.   If the lease commences after January 1, 2019, but before December 31, 2020, then you measure the lease on the commencement date.

Your calculation of the operating lease liability on January 1, 2019, is the present value of 1) the remaining minimum rental payments plus 2) any amount it is probable you will owe under a residual value guarantee.  The right-of-use asset equals the liability adjusted for lease prepayments/accruals, remaining lease incentives, unamortized initial direct costs, impairments and any previously recognized lease disposal cost obligations.

Going forward, you will continue to measure the lease liability at the present value of the remaining payments and reduce the right-of-use asset over the remaining term at a rate that results in straight line expense recognition for the lease.

Capital leases

For existing capital leases, the guidance for measurement results in a mere reclassification.  The capital lease asset and the capital lease obligation under the old standard become the amounts of the right-of-use asset and financing lease liability under the new standard.  If the leases have unamortized initial direct costs that meet requirements for capitalization under the new standard, these costs will be added to the right-of-use asset. If costs don’t meet the capitalization criteria under the new standard, you will write-off the related asset as an adjustment to beginning equity. Furthermore, you will account for these leases under the old capital lease accounting rules between January 1, 2019 and December 31, 2020.

Subsequent Accounting

For the most part beginning January 1, 2021 you will account for legacy leases in accordance with the new lease standard.  One exception is that legacy capital leases accounted for as financing leases are not subject to the requirement to be re-measured for changes in the amount that it is probable will be owed under residual value guarantees.

Other Considerations

You may be asking what discount rate should be used to calculate the present value.  I could write a whole other article on the subject but for now let me give you a much summarized definition:   The discount rate is the rate implicit in the lease or the incremental borrowing rate if the implicit rate is not readily determinable. A non-public company can make an accounting policy election to use a risk-free discount rate for all leases.

We covered a lot of ground on various transition issues. However, if you don’t plan to use the practical expedients, you will need to learn a little more about what to do with old capital leases being classified as operating leases under the new standard.  There could be other transition issues I haven’t addressed that are important to you but hopefully you at least have a picture of what implementation will look like for your company.